Emilia's Pizzeria: Authentic NY-Style Pizza in Berkeley
Emilia's Pizzeria is a hidden gem located at 2995 Shattuck Ave., Berkeley. Specializing in New York-style pizza, the establishment is known for its thin, airy crust that balances chewiness and flavor. Each pie is crafted with care by a single dedicated artisan, ensuring a homemade feel that resonates with customers. Favorites like the vegetarian and hot honey pizzas showcase a perfect blend of quality toppings and flavorful sauce, repeatedly garnering rave reviews. Whether dining in or ordering for pickup, patrons are encouraged to order early to savor this delightful experience that feels both personal and richly satisfying.
Photos & Gallery
Popular Menu Items
Sausage & Mushroom
Gina
House-Made Sausage Mushroom Red Onion Aleppo Pepper Flakes
Extra Cheese
Emilia's Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings
This place is a gem!! I cannot believe I lived pretty much next to it for 5 years and didn’t know about it!! The first time I tried the pizza was two days ago. I ordered both the vegetarian and the hot honey pizzas and it was delicious. I went back for the extra cheese pizza and once again, just divine!!! I actually love that it’s one person (maybe the owner?) making the pizza and taking their time. It’s visibly their craft. I can’t wait to bring it to all my friends and family to try.
Well, I just discovered my new favorite pizza place in SF. I’m from the east coast originally and this pie hearkens back to the classic NY style slice. Thin airy crust with just enough chew, great sauce with a little peppery kick, and toppings chosen with care.
This place is an absolute gem!! Our friend recommended us this place and we finally got around to try it. Make sure if you want to try this place that you order online early! Otherwise you will have to wait a bit to pick up your pizza. We got the Gina Calabrese and it was so delicious. It’s NY style pizza and it looks like there is only one person making all the pizzas so feels very homemade but super tasty! Will be back to try other pizzas.
Absolutely incredible pizza. I recently moved here from New Jersey and was told I'd never find NJ/NY pizza but boy were they wrong. The biggest thing to keep in mind is to check their website and call at 4pm to put in your order, it's easy. And they give you an estimated time of when your pizza will be ready (either dine in or take out) and he was spot on with that time. The crust, sauce, cheese, visual, aromas, everything was exactly what I want in a pizza. And btw cash only!
Good pizza! Kind of a hybrid Neopolitan-NY style. The toppings on the classic were delicious with fresh tomato flavor. I appreciated that the toppings weren’t overloaded and it helped preserve the crust undercarriage.
This is the best pizza ! The owner is great. I loved the entire experience. Must eat ASAP. Don’t wait until you get home. Have a picnic ! Fantastic ! For those that say it’s ‘ light on toppings ‘ ..that’s how real pizza is done. American pizza slathers tons of toppings and weighs down the pie. This is Italian !
The best. You need to go to the website and plan ahead but it’s well worth it. Every ingredient is delicious and the toppings are not too crowded - the crust has room to shine. The only time my pizza has turned out anything short of amazing was because of a distracting car accident nearby and he offered to remake the pizza since it got overcooked.
Keith is legit. A lot of pies this size are overtopped and have too much sauce and cheese. Not here. His balance is perfect. His sauce is sweet, and that’s not to my personal taste but it was still delicious. The dough is the star here. Complex, tangy and subtle hints of sour. Outstanding work. I hope he gets to a point where he can get staff and more space. We need more great pizzaiolos in the bay! I say that as one myself! Great job Keith!
Location
-
2995 Shattuck Ave., Berkeley, CA 94705, United States Hotline:
Welcome to Emilia's Pizzeria, a delightful culinary haven nestled at 2995 Shattuck Ave., Berkeley, CA. This charming pizzeria has quickly captured the hearts and taste buds of locals, becoming a must-try destination for pizza enthusiasts. With a focus on hand-crafted quality and authentic flavors, Emilia's Pizzeria combines New York-style traditions with a personal touch that elevates the pizza experience.
As you step inside, you’ll notice a unique atmosphere where one dedicated individual, possibly the owner, passionately creates each pie. This personal touch ensures that every pizza is not just food but a work of art. Customer reviews rave about the thin, airy crust that strikes the perfect balance between crispy and chewy. They describe the sauce as having a delightful peppery kick, complementing the carefully chosen toppings that enhance the overall flavor profile.
Thali Malagoli describes Emilia's as a hidden gem, expressing disbelief that they lived nearby for years without discovering this marvelous eatery. Indeed, the hustle and bustle of Berkeley can sometimes overshadow these culinary treasures, but Emilia's Pizzeria shines brightly with its commitment to exceptional taste and quality.
For those drawn to vegetarian options, dishes like the vegetarian pizza and delectable combinations such as the Gina Calabrese invoke a chorus of satisfied sighs from patrons. Others, like Albert Aydin, appreciate the classic NJ/NY pizza style that often evokes nostalgia with each bite, reminding them of their roots. The emphasis on fresh ingredients and the perfect blend of flavors makes it hard to settle for just one slice.
One cannot miss the famed hot honey pizza, a unique creation that promises an enticing balance of sweetness and spice. The sheer enthusiasm of fans who express their intent to spread the word about this delightful pizzeria speaks volumes about the quality and experience offered by Emilia’s.
As you plan your visit, be sure to check their website and place your order in advance. The pizzeria operates on a cash-only basis, a quaint nod to traditional establishments, and it often prompts eager customers to count down the minutes until they can collect their delicious pie. Emilia's Pizzeria isn’t just a place for a meal; it’s a destination where quality, familiarity, and flavor thrive, leaving every visitor craving more. Whether it's a casual night out or a gathering with friends and family, Emilia's promises a pizza experience worthy of your cravings.
- Accessibility
- Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Service options
- Offers takeaway
- No delivery
- Payments
- Accepts credit cards
- Credit cards